From the Mises Economics Blog comes an interesting review of the movie, Captain America. While I agree that the writers of the movie probably did not intend all of the assumptions made in this piece, it is interesting to explore how much of the movie is reflected in the political realities we see today in the United States.
Some of my favorite quotes from the article are as follows. "This SHIELD/HYDRA conjunction is a splendid analogue for the State
itself. The illusion is that the State, like SHIELD, is a “shield”: an
essential protector of life, liberty, and property against criminals,
foreign and domestic. The reality is
that the State, like the HYDRA-infested SHIELD, is a monstrous
institution, shot through with the most dastardly criminals of them all,
and hellbent on ensnaring in its coils as many people as possible, and
as tightly as it can get away with. The State, like the HYDRA-inflested SHIELD, either produces or
induces most of the violence in the world; and then it turns around and
uses that very turmoil to play on people’s fears, so as to justify its
expansion (like the proliferating heads of the mythical Hydra) and its
even tighter constriction of society, allegedly so it can “keep us
safe.”"
A second quote shows that "Like SHIELD/HYDRA, Washington (through such “Hydra heads” as NATO, the
U.S. military, the CIA, the NED, etc) has used mass deception and covert interventions (both hard and soft) to generate chaos so as to precipitate its own overt interventions, and to extend its hegemony. World history since the Second World War has been a tissue of such incidents."
The last quote I will borrow is the following, "One of the greatest moments in the film is when Captain America decides
not to try to purge HYDRA from SHIELD, as Nick Fury (played by Samuel L.
Jackson) wants to do, and as some minarchist (utopian) libertarians
would like to do with the State. Instead, he realizes that SHIELD and
HYDRA cannot be disentangled: certainly not practically, and perhaps not
even conceptually." This last quote is the critical one that needs to be examined today by those who feel that the government is no longer representative of the people. While there is no doubt that there are many problems in the government, is the ultimate solution one of restoration or re-creation?
No comments:
Post a Comment